In modern software projects, the choice of database directly affects the speed, security, scalability, and long-term success of the project. However, the abundance of open-source and commercial database solutions on the market can complicate the decision-making process for developers. In this guide, we comprehensively, technically, and simply compare the 4 most popular databases: MySQL, MariaDB, PostgreSQL, and MongoDB.
General Definitions
Database | Type | Data Model | Open Source | Best Use Case |
---|---|---|---|---|
MySQL | RDBMS | Relational (table-based) | ✅ | Web applications, WordPress, e-commerce |
MariaDB | RDBMS | Relational | ✅ | Those seeking a MySQL alternative, high performance |
PostgreSQL | ORDBMS | Object + Relational | ✅ | Big data, geographic data, enterprise solutions |
MongoDB | NoSQL | Document (JSON-like BSON) | ✅ | Real-time applications, flexible schema requirements |
1. MySQL: Powerful with Prevalence and Community Strength
Advantages:
-
Most widely used open-source database
-
Strong integration with systems like PHP, WordPress, Laravel
-
Comes as default on cPanel servers
Disadvantages:
-
Managed by Oracle (some versions are commercial)
-
Performance tuning limitations
Suitable for? SME websites, blogs, small to medium-sized projects
⚙️ 2. MariaDB: MySQL's Free and Fast Alternative
It is the open-source continuation of MySQL. Its developers were created by the founders of MySQL.
Advantages:
-
Fully compatible with MySQL (DROP-IN REPLACEMENT)
-
Faster read/write operations
-
Built-in replication technologies like Galera Cluster
Disadvantages:
-
Large enterprise support providers are generally focused on MySQL
Suitable for? High traffic sites, large databases, open-source supported systems
3. PostgreSQL: Enterprise Level with Advanced Features
Advantages:
-
Supports JSON, XML, GIS data types
-
ACID compliance is very strong
-
Most stable structure in multiple concurrent write operations
-
Advanced RDBMS features such as view, trigger, stored procedure
Disadvantages:
-
Steeper learning curve
-
Hosting panel support may be limited (e.g., cPanel, Plesk)
Suitable for? Enterprise applications, geographic information systems (GIS), finance, healthcare systems
4. MongoDB: The Flexible Power of the NoSQL World
Advantages:
-
Schema-less data structure (JSON-like documents)
-
Superior performance in real-time data
-
Automatic sharding (data partitioning)
-
High scalability and flexibility
Disadvantages:
-
ACID guarantee is limited (better after version 4.0)
-
Requires a learning process for developers who have learned SQL
Suitable for? Chat applications, IoT systems, large e-commerce catalogs, data streaming systems
Technical Comparison Table
Feature | MySQL | MariaDB | PostgreSQL | MongoDB |
---|---|---|---|---|
Data Structure | Tables | Tables | Tables + Object | Documents (JSON) |
ACID Compliance | Yes | Yes | Very strong | Partially (4.0+) |
JSON Support | Limited | Limited | Native and strong | Basic structure |
Performance (Read) | Medium | Fast | Stable | Very fast |
Performance (Write) | Medium | Fast | Good | High |
Distributed Structure | Limited | Galera Cluster | Logical Replication | Sharding |
Supporting Panels | cPanel, Plesk | cPanel, Plesk | Plesk, Webmin | Usually custom panel |
Impacts in Terms of SEO, Web Hosting, and Application Performance
-
In terms of SEO: Website speed is important. MySQL and MariaDB provide an advantage in terms of SEO because they work integrated with CMSs such as WordPress.
-
Web Hosting: MySQL/MariaDB is common in shared hosting.
-
Performance: PostgreSQL and MongoDB offer more stable and powerful performance in systems containing a lot of data.
Conclusion: Choose the Right Database for Your Project
-
Beginner or intermediate web project: MySQL or MariaDB
-
High-traffic content sites, SEO-optimized infrastructure: MariaDB
-
Corporate analysis systems, statistics, financial systems: PostgreSQL
-
Real-time data processing, projects requiring a flexible structure: MongoDB
Each database system has its strengths and weaknesses. The best database is the system that best suits the needs of your software.